Fix Venmo 'Server Returned an Error' (Payment Failed)

Updated: 11/29/2025

You try to pay a friend for dinner, and a red banner pops up: 'Server returned an error' or 'Transaction Declined'. The money stays in your account, but you can't move it. This vague error message is Venmo's way of saying 'We blocked this for security reasons' without telling you exactly why, usually to prevent scammers from learning how to bypass the filters.

Table of Contents

Why does Venmo block payments?

Venmo (owned by PayPal) uses an aggressive AI to detect fraud. Triggers include:

  • Sending exactly the same amount ($50) to the same person multiple times quickly.
  • Logging in while connected to a VPN.
  • Using a new bank account that hasn't been verified yet.

Method 1: Disable VPN and Proxy

This is the #1 cause of the 'Server Error'. Financial apps require a clean, traceable IP address.

Check Background Apps: Ensure apps like NordVPN, ExpressVPN, or Cloudflare (1.1.1.1) are completely toggled OFF.

Force close Venmo and try the transaction again on regular WiFi or LTE.

Method 2: Unlink and Re-link Bank

The connection token between Venmo and your bank (Plaid) might have expired.

Step 1: Settings

Go to the 'Me' tab > Settings (Gear icon) > Payment Methods.

Step 2: Remove

Tap on your bank account and select Remove.

Step 3: Add Again

Tap Add Bank or Card and log in via Plaid again. This refreshes the security permission.

Method 3: Send a Different Amount

If you are trying to send $100 and it fails, try sending $5. If the small amount goes through, the AI flagged the amount, not your account. You can send the rest in smaller chunks (but wait an hour between transfers to avoid spam detection).